Home Shop Cart Account

Flours & Grains

Pantry Favorites

Handcrafted Pottery

Home & Lifestyle

Store

Gifts Under 50 Dollars

Filter products by category, price, and more

The Old Mill Shop Online

Store Account Cart

© 2026 The Old Mill Shop Online. All rights reserved.

Gifts Under 50 Dollars | The Old Mill Shop Online

NEW

From Our Table Gift Set

$39.99

New0% OFF

NEW

Biscuit Lovers` Gift Set

$36.99

New0% OFF

NEW

Soup Sampler

$34.99

New0% OFF

-65%NEW

Old Forge Moonshine Cake Combo

$39.99

$14.00

New65% OFF

-65%NEW

Winter Soup Gift Set

$39.99

$14.00

New65% OFF

-65%NEW

Signature Pound Cake

$34.99

$12.25

New65% OFF

-65%NEW

The Pottery House Cafe Chocolate Pecan Pie

$39.99

$14.00

New65% OFF

-65%NEW

Oil And Vinegar Gift Set

$42.99

$15.05

New65% OFF

-65%NEW

Brittle Sampler Gift Set

$39.99

$14.00

New65% OFF

NEW

Old Forge Coconut Rum Cake

$49.99

New0% OFF

NEW

English Toffee

$29.99

New0% OFF

NEW

Cranberry Orange Cornmeal Cake

$44.99

New0% OFF